Choosing the right applicant tracking system (ATS) can make or break your recruitment process. Two platforms consistently dominate the conversation: SmartRecruiters and Greenhouse. Both solutions promise to streamline your hiring cycle, but can they actually deliver?

In this article, we'll evaluate the strengths, weaknesses, and real user experiences of SmartRecruiters and Greenhouse, and introduce an alternative that might just be the perfect fit for your organization.

100Hires

Attract, interview & hire
the best candidates faster

Tony Urban, CEO at Deckrobot, 11-50 employees

Overall Rating

5/5

Likelihood to Recommend

10/10

I've front loaded all my recruiting needs to 100hires :) Very intuitive to use. I'm not an HR person, thus, for me it's crucial that the tool is straight-forward to use yet powerful! Additionally, I really like that publishing job at 100hires automatically promotes it and gets you additional candidate leads

Powerful Applicant Tracking System with G Suite integration

Get 100Hires FREE

Get started for FREE, upgrade as you grow Easy setup No credit card required

SmartRecruiters vs Greenhouse: Pricing and Feature Comparison

SmartRecruiters positions itself as a collaborative, global ATS with strong marketing and talent sourcing capabilities.

Greenhouse focuses on structured hiring with robust analytics and diversity-and-inclusion features.

These systems take different approaches to solving recruitment challenges for enterprise clients. But what if you're not an enterprise client? 100Hires is an alternative solution, offering performance without complexity.

The following table compares prices and features of SmartRecruiters vs Greenhouse vs 100Hires.

Why struggle with complexity and hidden pricing?
100Hires gives you everything you need to streamline hiring – with a clean UI, fast setup, and transparent pricing from $49/month.

• No dev resources needed
• Works out of the box
• Affordable, scalable, and easy to use

Start your free trial of 100Hires today – no credit card required

User Interface and Ease of Use

SmartRecruiters: User-Friendly by Design

SmartRecruiters users praise the user-friendly interface, with feedback that the platform's clean design makes it easy for both recruiters and hiring managers to navigate. However, some users find the extensive customization options overwhelming, particularly for smaller teams.

Greenhouse: Structured but Complex

Greenhouse's structured approach helps standardize hiring processes, providing detailed candidate tracking and workflow management.

But users frequently report a steep learning curve. Many customers find navigation confusing, particularly when trying to locate specific candidate information quickly.

Candidate Experience and Job Posting

SmartRecruiters: Built-in Site Builder

SmartRecruiters' Attrax creates branded job pages, helping companies maintain consistent branding throughout the candidate experience without technical expertise.

The SmartDistribute bundle simplifies posting to over 300 job boards.

Greenhouse: API-First Approach

Greenhouse's Job Board API provides JSON-based capabilities instead of a drag-and-drop builder. While this appeals to technical teams, it typically requires developer resources for optimal implementation.

The MyGreenhouse candidate portal offers real-time status updates and interview scheduling, improving transparency for candidates throughout the hiring process.

Analytics and Reporting

SmartRecruiters: Access to the Data You Need

Through SmartAnalytics, SmartRecruiters offers insights into hiring performance, source effectiveness, and team productivity. The platform supports data-driven decision making with customizable reports and dashboards.

Users appreciate tracking metrics across global operations, including multi-currency reporting. However, some mention that the reporting interface could be more intuitive.

Greenhouse: Advanced Analytics with Limitations

Greenhouse excels in structured reporting and analytics, providing detailed insights into funnel performance and hiring metrics. The platform's Report Connector allows users to export live reports to Google Sheets.

However, some user reviews describe Greenhouse reporting as "clunky" and "click-heavy." The system requires multiple steps to generate basic reports, frustrating teams that need quick access to data.

Team Collaboration

SmartRecruiters: Built for Hiring Teams

SmartRecruiters' team collaboration features allow hiring teams to work together seamlessly. Team members can rate candidates, share feedback, and coordinate throughout the interview process.

However, some users express concerns about data visibility, noting that confidential information may be too accessible across team members.

Greenhouse: Structured Collaboration

Greenhouse provides collaboration tools like customizable scorecards and interview plans, promoting consistency in candidate evaluation and helping teams make data-driven decisions.

Greenhouse centralizes candidate information, interview notes, and feedback in one location. While this improves organization, some users feel the rigid structure limits flexibility in their hiring processes.

Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI) Features

SmartRecruiters: Growing DEI Focus

While SmartRecruiters has expanded its DEI capabilities, these features are still developing compared to competitors.

Greenhouse: Industry-Leading DEI Tools

Greenhouse leads the industry in DEI features, offering resume anonymization, bias warnings, and structured interview processes designed to promote fair evaluation of candidates.

Additionally, Greenhouse provides AI writing aids for inclusive job posts and GDPR configuration tools for compliant data handling.

Pricing and Support Considerations

SmartRecruiters: Enterprise-Focused Pricing

SmartRecruiters' user reviews claim annual price ranges of $468–1,200 per user, though exact pricing requires custom quotes. Premium customers receive 24/7 global support including phone and live chat options.

The platform's pricing model favors larger organizations, potentially making it less accessible for smaller teams with limited budgets.

Greenhouse: Premium Pricing Structure

While Greenhouse pricing is similarly opaque, estimated annual costs start at $6,500 per year but can reach upwards of $25,000 annually for larger organizations, positioning it as a premium solution.

Greenhouse offers tiered support levels from Essential to Expert plans, with higher tiers including dedicated customer success managers. User reviews frequently cite high costs as a significant drawback, particularly for growing companies that need to scale hiring operations efficiently.

Common Pain Points: Where Both Platforms Fall Short

Despite their strengths, both SmartRecruiters and Greenhouse share limitations that frustrate users:

Complexity Overload: Small HR teams often feel overwhelmed by feature-rich interfaces requiring extensive setup and ongoing management. Both platforms can feel like overkill for organizations with straightforward hiring needs.

Pricing Transparency: Quote-based pricing makes it difficult for companies to predict total costs, especially when scaling operations or adding team members.

Implementation Time: Both systems require significant setup time before teams can start hiring effectively, delaying time-to-value for organizations needing immediate results.

A Better Alternative: How 100Hires Outperforms Both Platforms

If you're evaluating SmartRecruiters vs Greenhouse, you're serious about improving your hiring process. However, the right question might not be which of these two to choose, but whether there's a better solution entirely.

100Hires was built specifically for companies that need results without complexity. Here's how it addresses the limitations of both platforms:

User Interface and Ease of Use: Best of Both Worlds

While SmartRecruiters offers user-friendly design but overwhelming customization, and Greenhouse provides structure but confusing navigation, 100Hires delivers intuitive simplicity without sacrificing functionality.

The platform requires zero training - your team can start hiring effectively from day one.

Candidate Experience: Superior Mobile-First Design
100Hires was built mobile-first from the ground up, ensuring candidates enjoy a smooth, fast application process on any device. The platform's career pages load quickly and look professional without requiring complex setup or technical configuration that other systems demand.

Analytics and Reporting: Actionable Insights
100Hires delivers metrics that matter most in an easy-to-understand format. Get instant insights into your hiring funnel, source effectiveness, and team performance without multiple clicks and confusing interfaces that frustrate users of both competitors.

Pricing and Support: Transparent and Responsive

Unlike SmartRecruiters' enterprise-focused pricing or Greenhouse's premium costs, 100Hires offers transparent, affordable pricing that scales with your team. You get responsive support from real humans - every customer receives help when needed.

Making Your Decision: SmartRecruiters vs Greenhouse vs 100Hires

Choosing between SmartRecruiters and Greenhouse depends on your organization's specific needs, budget, and technical resources. SmartRecruiters excels for global teams needing extensive integrations, while Greenhouse works well for data-driven organizations prioritizing DEI initiatives.

However, many hiring teams find both options create more complexity than value. If you're looking for a solution that combines the best features of both platforms while addressing their common limitations, 100Hires offers a compelling alternative.

The platform delivers enterprise-level functionality with startup-friendly simplicity, helping you hire better candidates faster without typical ATS headaches.

Ready to streamline your hiring process without complexity?

Try 100Hires free – no credit card required.

Experience how modern recruiting technology should work: simple, effective, and focused on results.